Good Trade 2?

[BeastinBraves10]

Same dude as last time proposed the following trade: i get torry holt, he gets steve smith



My Team:
Peyton Manning-QB
Steve Smith-WR (CAROLINA)
Joey Galloway-WR
Mike Furrey-WR
Marion Barber III-RB
Ladell Betts-RB
Antonio Gates-TE
Chris Chambers-WR-BENCH
Cedric Benson-RB-BENCH
DeAngelo Williams-RB-BENCH
Benjamin Watson-TE-BENCH
Jon Kitna- QB-BENCH
Stephen Gostkowski-K
NEW ENGLAND-DEFENSE
MINNESOTA-DEFENSE-BENCH


His Team:
Tom Brady-QB
Andre Johnson-WR
Santana Moss-WR
Torry Holt-WR
Shaun Alexander-RB
Clinton Portis-RB
Chris Cooley-TE
Dallas Clark-TE-BENCH
Philip Rivers-QB-BENCH
Jerious Norwood-RB-BENCH
Vincent Jackson-WR-BENCH
Neil Rackers-K
David Akers-K-BENCH
JACKSONVILLE-DEFENSE
CAROLINA-DEFENSE-BENCH



NO BIAS PLEASE!<!-- / message -->

[GrandMasterB]

I'd keep Steve Smith. When he's healthy, he's one of the top two or three receivers in the league. Really can't go wrong with either, but I think Smith is the better of the two.

[HaRdCoReBrAvEsFaN]

I like Holt better myself....but Holt has already said his rehab is well behind schedule so you have to chose the healthy player....

[BeastinBraves10]

need more results! i only have 2 votes